Paper Halloween Party Favors & Bag Fillers

Shop by category

616 results

    • Martha Stewart Crafts Treat Bags Party Favor Trick Or New Discontinued - Choose - Image 1 of 4
    • Martha Stewart Crafts Treat Bags Party Favor Trick Or New Discontinued - Choose - Image 2 of 4
    • Martha Stewart Crafts Treat Bags Party Favor Trick Or New Discontinued - Choose - Image 3 of 4
    • Martha Stewart Crafts Treat Bags Party Favor Trick Or New Discontinued - Choose - Image 4 of 4

    Martha Stewart Crafts Treat Bags Party Favor Trick Or New Discontinued - Choose

    Brand New ยท Martha Stewart
    $11.21
    Was: $14.95was - US $14.95
    $7.45 shipping
    • Lot Of 5 Vintage Halloween Paper Yoyo Party Favors Jack-O-Lanterns - Image 1 of 4
    • Lot Of 5 Vintage Halloween Paper Yoyo Party Favors Jack-O-Lanterns - Image 2 of 4
    • Lot Of 5 Vintage Halloween Paper Yoyo Party Favors Jack-O-Lanterns - Image 3 of 4
    • Lot Of 5 Vintage Halloween Paper Yoyo Party Favors Jack-O-Lanterns - Image 4 of 4

    Lot Of 5 Vintage Halloween Paper Yoyo Party Favors Jack-O-Lanterns

    Pre-Owned ยท Unbranded
    $41.00
    Was: $50.00was - US $50.00
    or Best Offer
    $8.30 shipping
    • Fun Express Value Halloween Handout Kit, Bulk 788 Piece - Image 1 of 2
    • Fun Express Value Halloween Handout Kit, Bulk 788 Piece - Image 2 of 2

    Fun Express Value Halloween Handout Kit, Bulk 788 Piece

    Brand New
    $31.99
    Was: $36.79was - US $36.79
    Free shipping
  • Fun Express Scooby-Doo! Halloween Favor Boxes, 6 1/4" x 6",12 Pcs. - Image 1 of 1

    Fun Express Scooby-Doo! Halloween Favor Boxes, 6 1/4" x 6",12 Pcs.

    Brand New
    $16.98
    Was: $19.53was - US $19.53
    Free shipping
    4 watching
  • RARE Vintage 80s Lisa Frank HALLOWEEN HANDOUT Stickers party favors SEALED - Image 1 of 4

    New ListingRARE Vintage 80s Lisa Frank HALLOWEEN HANDOUT Stickers party favors SEALED

    Brand New ยท Lisa Frank
    $145.00
    Free shipping
  • Vintage Beistle Halloween Retro Owl & Cat Masks 9.5" 2 Pack 1940, 2012 USA - Image 1 of 4

    Vintage Beistle Halloween Retro Owl & Cat Masks 9.5" 2 Pack 1940, 2012 USA

    Brand New ยท Beistle
    $7.97
    or Best Offer
    $4.49 shipping
    19 watching
  • Halloween Party Favor 12 Mini Boxes In Package, 24 Total Tattoos BNIP - Image 1 of 4

    Halloween Party Favor 12 Mini Boxes In Package, 24 Total Tattoos BNIP

    Brand New
    $3.99
    or Best Offer
    $6.95 shipping
  • Vintage Halloween Disney Winnie the Pooh Paper Trick or Treat Bags 30 Count 6x4 - Image 1 of 3

    Vintage Halloween Disney Winnie the Pooh Paper Trick or Treat Bags 30 Count 6x4

    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $8.89
    Free shipping
    Only 1 left!
  • Amscan Halloween Glitter Paper Black Chandelier Decorating Kit (17 Pieces) - Image 1 of 1

    Amscan Halloween Glitter Paper Black Chandelier Decorating Kit (17 Pieces)

    Brand New ยท Amscan
    $15.99
    Free shipping
  • Vintage Paper Treat Bags Halloween Party Favors 4" mini Pumpkin Trick 16 Unused - Image 1 of 4

    Vintage Paper Treat Bags Halloween Party Favors 4" mini Pumpkin Trick 16 Unused

    Open Box
    $4.00
    Was: $5.00was - US $5.00
    or Best Offer
    $5.00 shipping
  • Halloween Favors Skeleton Couple Scrapbook Stickers Labels Envelope Seals - Image 1 of 1

    Halloween Favors Skeleton Couple Scrapbook Stickers Labels Envelope Seals

    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $2.39 to $4.59
    Free shipping
  • 20 Monster High Friends Forever Stickers Party Favors Teacher Supply Halloween - Image 1 of 1

    20 Monster High Friends Forever Stickers Party Favors Teacher Supply Halloween

    Brand New ยท Disney
    $3.15
    Free shipping
    10 watching
  • vtg. 5 Pc Halloween Party Favors Lot. Straws, Danglers, Napkins, Tablecloth - Image 1 of 4

    vtg. 5 Pc Halloween Party Favors Lot. Straws, Danglers, Napkins, Tablecloth

    Brand New
    $28.00
    $21.40 shipping
  • Trunk-Or-Treat Religious Halloween Assortment - Toys - 100 Pieces - Image 1 of 3

    Trunk-Or-Treat Religious Halloween Assortment - Toys - 100 Pieces

    Brand New ยท Oriental Trading
    $23.98
    Was: $27.58was - US $27.58
    Free shipping
  • Halloween Party Favors - DIY Crafts Stickers for Kids - Kids Halloween Decoratio - Image 1 of 4

    Halloween Party Favors - DIY Crafts Stickers for Kids - Kids Halloween Decoratio

    Brand New
    $16.99
    Free shipping
  • Halloween Party Favors 100 PCS - Trinkets for Kids Carnival Prizes Toys Bulk - Image 1 of 4

    Halloween Party Favors 100 PCS - Trinkets for Kids Carnival Prizes Toys Bulk

    Brand New
    $19.59
    or Best Offer
    $6.27 shipping
  • Amscan Halloween Party Favor 8 Sticker Strips: Cats, Pumpkins, Bats, Ghost New - Image 1 of 4

    Amscan Halloween Party Favor 8 Sticker Strips: Cats, Pumpkins, Bats, Ghost New

    Brand New ยท Amscan
    $2.50
    Was: $5.00was - US $5.00
    or Best Offer
    $5.99 shipping
  • 48 HAPPY HALLOWEEN PARTY FAVORS ENVELOPE SEALS SCRAPBOOK STICKERS 1.2" ROUND - Image 1 of 1

    48 HAPPY HALLOWEEN PARTY FAVORS ENVELOPE SEALS SCRAPBOOK STICKERS 1.2" ROUND

    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $2.21
    Free shipping
  • Halloween Pumpkin Pinata - Party Supplies - 1 Piece - Image 1 of 1

    Halloween Pumpkin Pinata - Party Supplies - 1 Piece

    Brand New
    $25.33
    Was: $29.13was - US $29.13
    Free shipping
  • Disney Star Wars Halloween Tattoo Treats 20 Boxes 100 Tattoos New - Image 1 of 4

    Disney Star Wars Halloween Tattoo Treats 20 Boxes 100 Tattoos New

    Brand New
    $6.79
    Free shipping
  • Halloween 6 Pcs Fun Party Favor Toys Halloween Pins & Decor for Kids & Adults - Image 1 of 4

    Halloween 6 Pcs Fun Party Favor Toys Halloween Pins & Decor for Kids & Adults

    Brand New ยท Harvey
    $45.00
    $10.40 shipping
  • Sesame Street 10 Trick or Treat Halloween candy cake boxes window bakery tissue - Image 1 of 1

    Sesame Street 10 Trick or Treat Halloween candy cake boxes window bakery tissue

    Brand New ยท Sesame Street
    $19.99
    or Best Offer
    $4.99 shipping
  • 36 Sets Halloween Gifts 36 Halloween Cat Greeting Cards with 108 Glow Sticks Hal - Image 1 of 4

    36 Sets Halloween Gifts 36 Halloween Cat Greeting Cards with 108 Glow Sticks Hal

    Brand New
    $27.45
    Free shipping
  • 20 Care Bears Happy Halloween Stickers Party Favors Teacher Supply rewards - Image 1 of 1

    20 Care Bears Happy Halloween Stickers Party Favors Teacher Supply rewards

    Brand New
    $3.15
    Free shipping
    5 watching
  • 50 Happy Halloween Trick or Treat Stickers Party Favors Teacher Supply Candy - Image 1 of 1

    50 Happy Halloween Trick or Treat Stickers Party Favors Teacher Supply Candy

    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $3.50
    Free shipping
  • FUN WORLD Halloween Skeleton Party Favor Treat Bags 1995 Vintage 40 Ct NOS USA - Image 1 of 2

    FUN WORLD Halloween Skeleton Party Favor Treat Bags 1995 Vintage 40 Ct NOS USA

    Brand New
    $4.77
    or Best Offer
    $4.50 shipping
  • Halloween Mini Puzzles - Toys - 12 Pieces - Image 1 of 1

    Halloween Mini Puzzles - Toys - 12 Pieces

    Brand New
    $14.48
    Was: $16.65was - US $16.65
    $6.99 shipping
  • Gothic Horror Party Favors 1 5 10 20 50pcs Sets Bulk Variety Dollar Lots Kids - Image 1 of 4

    Gothic Horror Party Favors 1 5 10 20 50pcs Sets Bulk Variety Dollar Lots Kids

    Unique Collectible Bills. Cult Classic & Popular Films.
    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $0.99 to $49.99
    $0.69 shipping
    15 watching
  • Halloween Boredom Buster Kit - Activities for Kids & Adults - 608 Pieces - Image 1 of 1

    New ListingHalloween Boredom Buster Kit - Activities for Kids & Adults - 608 Pieces

    Brand New
    $63.24
    Was: $72.73was - US $72.73
    Free shipping
  • SWIRLLINE 100 Pcs Halloween Toy Gifts for Kids Party Favors Trick or Treat Toys - Image 1 of 4

    SWIRLLINE 100 Pcs Halloween Toy Gifts for Kids Party Favors Trick or Treat Toys

    Brand New
    $18.30
    or Best Offer
    $6.27 shipping
  • Zombie Pinata Halloween Decoration, Party Decor, 1 Piece - Image 1 of 2

    Zombie Pinata Halloween Decoration, Party Decor, 1 Piece

    Brand New
    $25.10
    Was: $28.87was - US $28.87
    Free shipping
    5 watching
  • Religious Halloween Bookmark Asst - Stationery - 48 Pieces - Image 1 of 1

    Religious Halloween Bookmark Asst - Stationery - 48 Pieces

    Brand New ยท Oriental Trading
    $15.00
    Was: $17.25was - US $17.25
    $6.99 shipping
  • Halloween Disney Mickey & Friends Paper Trick or Treat Bags 40 Count 6 x 4 - Image 1 of 3

    Halloween Disney Mickey & Friends Paper Trick or Treat Bags 40 Count 6 x 4

    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $2.99
    $7.90 shipping
  • Halloween Party Favors 11 Pumpkins Trick Or Treat Carnival Fall Festival READ - Image 1 of 2

    Halloween Party Favors 11 Pumpkins Trick Or Treat Carnival Fall Festival READ

    Brand New
    $8.99
    or Best Offer
    $5.99 shipping
  • Spider Web Carnival Haunted House Halloween Party Favor Paper Treat Boxes - Image 1 of 1

    Spider Web Carnival Haunted House Halloween Party Favor Paper Treat Boxes

    Brand New ยท Amscan
    $12.77
    Free shipping
  • Halloween Party Favor, 2 Mini Pencils, Sharpener, Notepad, Eraser BNIP - Image 1 of 2

    Halloween Party Favor, 2 Mini Pencils, Sharpener, Notepad, Eraser BNIP

    Brand New ยท Amscan
    $2.99
    or Best Offer
    $6.95 shipping
  • Hyde Eek! Target Halloween Classroom Bingo Game 24 Cards 600 Chips Pumpkin Party - Image 1 of 4

    Hyde Eek! Target Halloween Classroom Bingo Game 24 Cards 600 Chips Pumpkin Party

    Brand New ยท Hyde
    $5.21
    Was: $6.95was - US $6.95
    or Best Offer
    $6.15 shipping
  • New Halloween Joke Scratch-Off Cards Trick or Treat Party Favor Gift - Image 1 of 2

    New Halloween Joke Scratch-Off Cards Trick or Treat Party Favor Gift

    Brand New ยท Oriental Trading
    $10.00
    $4.99 shipping
  • Medium Ghoul Gang Halloween Gift Bags - Party Supplies - 12 Pieces - Image 1 of 1

    Medium Ghoul Gang Halloween Gift Bags - Party Supplies - 12 Pieces

    Brand New
    $15.00
    Was: $17.25was - US $17.25
    $6.99 shipping
  • SWIRLLINE 100 Pcs Halloween Toy Gifts for Kids Party Favors Trick or Treat Toys - Image 1 of 4

    SWIRLLINE 100 Pcs Halloween Toy Gifts for Kids Party Favors Trick or Treat Toys

    Brand New
    $24.30
    or Best Offer
    Free shipping
  • Halloween Party Favor Pack 12ct Activity Pads Trick Or Treat Prizes - Image 1 of 4

    Halloween Party Favor Pack 12ct Activity Pads Trick Or Treat Prizes

    Brand New ยท Amscan
    $4.71
    Was: $7.85was - US $7.85
    or Best Offer
    $8.64 shipping
  • BOO Ghost Halloween Party Favors Labels Scrapbook Stickers Envelope Seals - Image 1 of 1

    BOO Ghost Halloween Party Favors Labels Scrapbook Stickers Envelope Seals

    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $2.20 to $4.70
    Free shipping
  • Vintage Halloween Pumpkin Jack-O-Lantern Piรฑata - Party Supplies - 1 Piece - Image 1 of 4

    Vintage Halloween Pumpkin Jack-O-Lantern Piรฑata - Party Supplies - 1 Piece

    Pre-Owned ยท Unbranded
    $7.99
    $8.71 shipping
    0 bids
    4d 12h
  • 50 Halloween Trick or Treat Stickers Party Favors Teacher Supply bat ghost 1.5" - Image 1 of 1

    50 Halloween Trick or Treat Stickers Party Favors Teacher Supply bat ghost 1.5"

    Brand New
    $3.50
    Free shipping
  • Disney Halloween Treat Sacks Loot Paper Bag Party Favors 40 Bags - Image 1 of 4

    Disney Halloween Treat Sacks Loot Paper Bag Party Favors 40 Bags

    Brand New ยท Disney
    $17.77
    or Best Offer
    Free shipping
    Only 1 left!
  • Peanuts Snoopy Woodstock Vintage Hallmark Halloween Party Decoration Paper NEW - Image 1 of 4

    Peanuts Snoopy Woodstock Vintage Hallmark Halloween Party Decoration Paper NEW

    Brand New ยท Hallmark
    $14.94
    or Best Offer
    $7.60 shipping
  • 120 Pieces Halloween Scratch Off Cards Halloween DIY Scratch Prize Cards 4 - Image 1 of 4

    120 Pieces Halloween Scratch Off Cards Halloween DIY Scratch Prize Cards 4

    Brand New
    $21.02
    Free shipping
    2 watching
  • 120 Count Halloween Happy Haunting Disney Princess Paper Trick or Treat Bags 6x4 - Image 1 of 4

    120 Count Halloween Happy Haunting Disney Princess Paper Trick or Treat Bags 6x4

    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $16.89
    Free shipping
  • Halloween 10 Count Favor Boxes Lot Of 3 Orange & Black Spider Webs Party Bags - Image 1 of 4

    Halloween 10 Count Favor Boxes Lot Of 3 Orange & Black Spider Webs Party Bags

    Brand New
    $7.95
    $9.21 shipping
  • VTG Halloween Horrors Paper Treat Candy Bags 46 CT Pumpkin Bat Yellow Orange - Image 1 of 4

    VTG Halloween Horrors Paper Treat Candy Bags 46 CT Pumpkin Bat Yellow Orange

    Open Box
    $5.00
    or Best Offer
    $11.95 shipping
  • ArtCreativity Halloween Coloring Books for Kids โ€“ 20 Pack Mini 5โ€ร—7โ€ White - Image 1 of 4

    ArtCreativity Halloween Coloring Books for Kids โ€“ 20 Pack Mini 5โ€ร—7โ€ White

    Brand New
    $18.09
    Free shipping
  • Spider Web Carnival Haunted House Halloween Party Favor Paper Treat Boxes 5ct - Image 1 of 4

    Spider Web Carnival Haunted House Halloween Party Favor Paper Treat Boxes 5ct

    Brand New ยท Amscan
    $9.85
    or Best Offer
    $5.49 shipping
  • Lot of 5 Halloween themed children books classroom preschool homeschool - Image 1 of 1

    Lot of 5 Halloween themed children books classroom preschool homeschool

    Brand New
    $15.99
    Free shipping
  • Happy Halloween Pickup Truck Pumpkin Scrapbook Stickers Halloween Envelope Seals - Image 1 of 1

    Happy Halloween Pickup Truck Pumpkin Scrapbook Stickers Halloween Envelope Seals

    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $2.39 to $4.59
    Free shipping
  • 24 Sheets Halloween Stickers DIY Crafts for Kids Party Favors Decorations ๐ŸŽƒ - Image 1 of 4

    24 Sheets Halloween Stickers DIY Crafts for Kids Party Favors Decorations ๐ŸŽƒ

    Brand New
    $12.12
    Free shipping
  • Lot of 3 Vintage Halloween Paper Trick or Treat Candy Favor Bags (40 per pack) - Image 1 of 4

    Lot of 3 Vintage Halloween Paper Trick or Treat Candy Favor Bags (40 per pack)

    Brand New
    $14.00
    or Best Offer
    $4.47 shipping
  • Halloween Favors Haunted House Scrapbook Stickers Labels Envelope Seals - Image 1 of 1

    Halloween Favors Haunted House Scrapbook Stickers Labels Envelope Seals

    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $2.39 to $4.59
    Free shipping
  • Halloween Happy Haunting Disney Princess Paper Trick or Treat Bags 40 Count 6x4 - Image 1 of 2

    Halloween Happy Haunting Disney Princess Paper Trick or Treat Bags 40 Count 6x4

    Brand New ยท Unbranded
    $2.99
    $7.90 shipping
  • Halloween Stationery Sets - Stationery - 12 Pieces - Image 1 of 1

    Halloween Stationery Sets - Stationery - 12 Pieces

    Brand New
    $19.98
    Was: $22.98was - US $22.98
    Free shipping
  • Summer Fun Last Day of School Kit Assortment May Vary - Image 1 of 2

    Summer Fun Last Day of School Kit Assortment May Vary

    Brand New ยท Oriental Trading
    $139.99
    Was: $160.99was - US $160.99
    Free shipping

You may also like