Thanksgiving Collectibles

New Listing2 Joe Spencer Native American Indian Dolls - Gathered Traditions Sean & Shawna
Pre-Owned
$60.00
$27.79 shipping
0 bids
4d 4h
Fiber Optic Thanksgiving Harvest Scarecrow Statue Halloween 13" Tall
Pre-Owned
$17.99
or Best Offer
$6.41 shipping
0 bids
2d 2h
L E Smith Glass Turkey Covered Candy Dishes Thanksgiving Lot of 10 great for par
Pre-Owned
$219.99
$69.99 shipping
0 bids
6d 5h
Lot of 3 Fall Thanksgiving Shelf Sitters Forever Beautiful Boy Girls Figurines
Pre-Owned
$7.50
$18.95 shipping
0 bids
2d 17h
Byers' Choice The Carolers Thanksgiving Pilgrim Boy With Turkey 1997
Pre-Owned · Byers' Choice
$10.00
$14.40 shipping
2 bids
4m 33s
Dept 56 Thanksgiving at Grandmother’s House #55358 Snow Village Retired TESTED
New (Other) · Department 56
$110.00
$21.28 shipping
1 bid
1h 4m
Byers Choice The Carolers Pilgrim Man Holding a Gourd Thanksgiving 1997
Pre-Owned
$18.00
$14.40 shipping
1 bid
9m 6s
New Listing300 EARLY 1900's POSTCARDS ALBUM, 6 HALLOWEEN, THANKSGIVING CHRISTMAS EASTER
Pre-Owned
$299.99
$11.07 shipping
0 bids
6d 6h
Thanksgiving Artist Folk Art Painted Vaillancourt Style Chalkware Turkey Figure
Pre-Owned
$38.99
$11.05 shipping
0 bids
1d 23h
Pottery Barn Faux Pumpkin And Gourd Fall Holiday Decor Thanksgiving
Pre-Owned
$14.99
$10.00 shipping
0 bids
3d 17h
New ListingVintage Thanksgiving Turkey Don Featherstone Union Products. Light-up Blow Mold
Pre-Owned
$100.00
$29.54 shipping
0 bids
6d
1996 HALLMARK Merry Miniatures GIVING THANKS Chipmunk & Mouse Pilgrims
Pre-Owned · Hallmark
$5.88
$5.02 shipping
1 bid
18h 56m
1996 Thanksgiving We Bear Thanks Cherished Teddies Miniatures Room Box
Pre-Owned
$29.00
or Best Offer
$31.20 shipping
0 bids
4d 1h
Vintage Megatoys 'Giblet' animated turkey w a tune - 14 inch tall - works!
Pre-Owned
$55.00
or Best Offer
$21.15 shipping
0 bids
5d 5h
Lot of 2 Vintage 1950’s Gurley Native American Indian Boy Thanksgiving Candle
Pre-Owned · Gurley's
$4.99
$8.30 shipping
0 bids
4d 5h
Hallmark Merry Miniatures Thanksgiving Figurines 1980’s,1990’s Vintage-lot of 14
Brand New
$9.99
$11.95 shipping
1 bid
2d 6h
17- Assorted Vintage Gurley Thanksgiving Turkey Pilgrims Lot Read Candles
Pre-Owned · Read
$30.00
$10.00 shipping
0 bids
3d 1h
Vintage Halloween Thanksgiving Party Crepe Paper Hay Stack Party Favors/Nut Cups
Pre-Owned
$45.00
$5.00 shipping
0 bids
18h 3m
New Listingdon featherstone turkey blow mold
Refurbished · Pilgrim
$40.00
$10.00 shipping
1 bid
6d 2h
New CRACKER BARREL Bountiful Harvest Squirrel & ACORN Salt Pepper Shakers 2007
Brand New
$7.95
$6.80 shipping
0 bids
3d 22h
Papier Mache Turkey Candy Container
Pre-Owned
$55.00
or Best Offer
$10.00 shipping
0 bids
4h 43m
Vintage 1995 Thanksgiving Turkey Don Featherstone Union Products BLOW MOLD
Pre-Owned
$99.99
$24.96 shipping
0 bids
3d 18h
Mark Roberts Halloween Fall Pumpkin Pie 9" Elf Fairy Doll Ornament
Pre-Owned
$9.99
$8.58 shipping
0 bids
5d 4h
4 Piece Pilgrim Family Costco Hand Painted Thanksgiving Figures 19"/17”/14”/11”
Pre-Owned
$49.99
or Best Offer
$29.99 shipping
0 bids
5d 1h
Blossom Bucket Give Thanks Thanksgiving Turkey & Pumpkin B. Lloyd 2009
Pre-Owned
$6.99
$9.95 shipping
0 bids
8d 21h
Vintage Thanksgiving Turkey Don Featherstone Union Products Lights Up BLOW MOLD
Pre-Owned
$119.99
$27.79 shipping
1 bid
3d 21h
New ListingVINTAGE LEFTON Thanksgiving Ceramic Boy & Girl Squirrel Pumpkin Ceramic set
Pre-Owned · Lefton
$7.99
$11.95 shipping
0 bids
6d 19h
Vtg Midwest Cannon Falls Native American Thanksgiving Indian Folk Art Pair EUC
Pre-Owned
$39.99
$14.40 shipping
0 bids
3d 18h
Large Vtg Erzgebirge Wooden PILGRIM Man w Corn Pumpkin CANDLE Stick Holder
Pre-Owned
$29.95
$10.75 shipping
0 bids
4d 1h
Annalee 2016 Thanksgiving Football Kickoff Kicker Game Day Tom Turkey
Pre-Owned
$19.99
$8.71 shipping
0 bids
5d 21h
Roman Glazed Ceramic Turkey 5.25” Figurine Thanksgiving, Fall, Autumn Decoration
Brand New
$9.99
$10.95 shipping
0 bids
3d 6h
VTG Turkey Figure Candy Holders Containers Sonsco Japan Paper Mache THANKSGIVING
$20.00
$8.00 shipping
1 bid
3d 1h
6 Vtg 60’80s Thanksgiving Valentines Die Cut Paper Decorations Hallmark
$7.00
$8.50 shipping
0 bids
1d 19h
Vintage 1913 Thanksgiving Wishes postcard, with Waynesboro, PA postmark
$1.99
or Best Offer
$0.80 shipping
0 bids
5d 5h
Vintage Waterford Fall / Thanksgiving "Autumn Turkey "Glass Hanging Ornament NWT
Pre-Owned · Waterford
$56.00
$8.50 shipping
3 bids
2d 5h
Vintage Japan Papier Mâché Turkey Pair Candy Container Thanksgiving Figurines
Pre-Owned
$6.50
$8.99 shipping
2 bids
1d 5h
New ListingAnnalee Turkey Pilgrim Thanksgiving Doll Holiday Decoration With Tag 2008
Pre-Owned
$4.99
$10.60 shipping
0 bids
6d 22h
Thanksgiving Decor - Ceramic Bag with Turkey
Pre-Owned
$2.00
or Best Offer
$8.71 shipping
0 bids
1d 1h
Vintage Thanksgiving Turkey Figurine Autumn Fall Harvest Table Top Home Decor
Pre-Owned
$12.00
or Best Offer
$6.02 shipping
0 bids
2h 55m
Vintage Melted Plastic Popcorn Thanksgiving Indian Man & Woman
Brand New
$50.00
or Best Offer
$16.65 shipping
0 bids
3d 3h
Turkey Plush Thanksgiving Stuffed Toy Vintage Animal Decor Hallmark Centerpiece
Pre-Owned
$25.00
Free shipping
0 bids
3d 6h
Suzi Skoglund Pilgrim Girl Thanksgiving Figurine w/Pie
Pre-Owned
$21.99
$11.05 shipping
0 bids
4d 4h
Old West German Composition Tom Turkey Thanksgiving Decoration #2
Pre-Owned
$9.99
$11.95 shipping
0 bids
22h 12m
Thanksgiving Ceramic Pottery Cornucopia Horn of Plenty Centerpiece E
Pre-Owned
$9.99
or Best Offer
$11.00 shipping
0 bids
4d 3h
New ListingVintage Silvestri Pilgrim Thanksgiving Holiday Boy Figure Holding Corn 10”
Pre-Owned
$10.90
$11.00 shipping
0 bids
9d 6h
NEW Blue Sky Clayworks Halloween cat in Pumpkin with Pumpkin tail Tea Light
Brand New
$34.99
or Best Offer
$12.95 shipping
0 bids
2d 6h
Antique Vntg German Bisque Thanksgiving Turkey Bird Dollhouse Miniature Animal
Pre-Owned · Unbranded
$50.00
Free shipping
0 bids
4d 6h
Vintage Post Cards (8) Thanksgiving 1906 Post Cards Holiday Some Embossed
Pre-Owned
$2.99
$4.80 shipping
1 bid
21h 52m
(3) Thanksgiving Vintage Style Postcards & (6) Flash Cards E
Brand New
$12.99
or Best Offer
$5.25 shipping
0 bids
4d 3h
THANKSGIVING PILGRIMS COUPLE 10” BOY & GIRL CERAMIC FIGURINES HOLDING BASKETS.
Pre-Owned · Pilgrim
$19.98
$14.85 shipping
0 bids
3d 2h
Vintage 1960’s Gurley Native American Indian Man Thanksgiving Candle Buffalo, NY
New (Other) · Gurley's
$1.99
or Best Offer
$6.02 shipping
0 bids
5d 4h
New ListingTHE PILGRIM PAIR 2015 Salt Pepper Shakers NIB 5" tall Publix collectibles
Brand New
$8.99
or Best Offer
$10.00 shipping
0 bids
6d 6h
VINTAGE LOT OF 18 GURLEY THANKSGIVING CANDLES PILGRIMS TURKEY INDIANS
Pre-Owned · Gurley's
$125.00
or Best Offer
$10.00 shipping
0 bids
6h 49m
Lot of Seasonal Fall & Thanksgiving Decor
Pre-Owned
$5.00
or Best Offer
$10.00 shipping
0 bids
3h 34m
4 Piece Vintage Gurley Thanksgiving Candle Lot Turkey Pilgrim
Pre-Owned · Gurley's
$50.00
$15.43 shipping
0 bids
4d 6h
New ListingVintage double sided fall autumn Thanksgiving double sided wall quilt pilgrims
Pre-Owned
$15.99
$10.50 shipping
0 bids
6d 22h
Vintage 1978 Pom Pom Thanksgiving Ornaments
Pre-Owned
$11.00
$7.60 shipping
0 bids
3d 4h
Vtg Danish Made Pilgrim Honeycomb Thanksgiving Decoration Handmade in Denmark
Pre-Owned
$18.00
$6.02 shipping
0 bids
21h 13m
Thanksgiving Pilgrim Bear Figurine Planter-Fall Harvest Barrel-CuteCeramic Decor
Pre-Owned · Native American
$8.45
$8.71 shipping
0 bids
2h 35m
2 New Tahua Pottery Christmas Reindeer Figurines. Home Decor Xmas Holiday
Brand New
$34.00
$9.00 shipping
0 bids
5d 22h

Best selling

See All

Lenox Mini Pumpkin 10 Miniature Tree Ornaments Thanksgiving Halloween
(1)
$86.90 New
Lenox Autumn Favorites Miniature Tree Ornaments Set of 10 Fall Pumpkin
(3)
$75.00 New
$65.95 Used
LED Icicle Lights Outdoor Christmas Decorations 400led 8 Multicolor
$34.54 New
Old World Christmas 24156 Glass Blown Pilgrim Thanksgiving Ornament
(2)
$22.35 New
$18.99 Used
2013 Hallmark Giving Thanks 4th Snoopy Peanuts Gang Monthly Ornament Series
(5)
$25.47 New
$16.95 Used
2021 Hallmark Ornament Friends "The One With All The Thanksgivings" Magic
$17.95 New
$12.59 Used
Publix The Pilgrim Pair Thanksgiving Napkin Rings Holders Pilgrims Box 102476
$12.99 New
$11.99 Used
2022 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament Snoopy Balloon Float In Macy’s Parade Peanuts
(1)
$9.49 New

Motors

Clothing & Accessories

Sporting goods

Electronics

Business & Industrial

Jewelry & Watches

Collectibles & Art

Home & garden

Other categories

Thanksgiving Collectibles

Shop by category

320 results

New Listing2 Joe Spencer Native American Indian Dolls - Gathered Traditions Sean & Shawna

Fiber Optic Thanksgiving Harvest Scarecrow Statue Halloween 13" Tall

L E Smith Glass Turkey Covered Candy Dishes Thanksgiving Lot of 10 great for par

Lot of 3 Fall Thanksgiving Shelf Sitters Forever Beautiful Boy Girls Figurines

Byers' Choice The Carolers Thanksgiving Pilgrim Boy With Turkey 1997

Dept 56 Thanksgiving at Grandmother’s House #55358 Snow Village Retired TESTED

Byers Choice The Carolers Pilgrim Man Holding a Gourd Thanksgiving 1997

New Listing300 EARLY 1900's POSTCARDS ALBUM, 6 HALLOWEEN, THANKSGIVING CHRISTMAS EASTER

Thanksgiving Artist Folk Art Painted Vaillancourt Style Chalkware Turkey Figure

Pottery Barn Faux Pumpkin And Gourd Fall Holiday Decor Thanksgiving

New ListingVintage Thanksgiving Turkey Don Featherstone Union Products. Light-up Blow Mold

1996 HALLMARK Merry Miniatures GIVING THANKS Chipmunk & Mouse Pilgrims

1996 Thanksgiving We Bear Thanks Cherished Teddies Miniatures Room Box

Vintage Megatoys 'Giblet' animated turkey w a tune - 14 inch tall - works!

Lot of 2 Vintage 1950’s Gurley Native American Indian Boy Thanksgiving Candle

Hallmark Merry Miniatures Thanksgiving Figurines 1980’s,1990’s Vintage-lot of 14

17- Assorted Vintage Gurley Thanksgiving Turkey Pilgrims Lot Read Candles

Vintage Halloween Thanksgiving Party Crepe Paper Hay Stack Party Favors/Nut Cups

New Listingdon featherstone turkey blow mold

New CRACKER BARREL Bountiful Harvest Squirrel & ACORN Salt Pepper Shakers 2007

Papier Mache Turkey Candy Container

Vintage 1995 Thanksgiving Turkey Don Featherstone Union Products BLOW MOLD

Mark Roberts Halloween Fall Pumpkin Pie 9" Elf Fairy Doll Ornament

4 Piece Pilgrim Family Costco Hand Painted Thanksgiving Figures 19"/17”/14”/11”

Blossom Bucket Give Thanks Thanksgiving Turkey & Pumpkin B. Lloyd 2009

Vintage Thanksgiving Turkey Don Featherstone Union Products Lights Up BLOW MOLD

New ListingVINTAGE LEFTON Thanksgiving Ceramic Boy & Girl Squirrel Pumpkin Ceramic set

Vtg Midwest Cannon Falls Native American Thanksgiving Indian Folk Art Pair EUC

Large Vtg Erzgebirge Wooden PILGRIM Man w Corn Pumpkin CANDLE Stick Holder

Annalee 2016 Thanksgiving Football Kickoff Kicker Game Day Tom Turkey

Roman Glazed Ceramic Turkey 5.25” Figurine Thanksgiving, Fall, Autumn Decoration

VTG Turkey Figure Candy Holders Containers Sonsco Japan Paper Mache THANKSGIVING

6 Vtg 60’80s Thanksgiving Valentines Die Cut Paper Decorations Hallmark

Vintage 1913 Thanksgiving Wishes postcard, with Waynesboro, PA postmark

Vintage Waterford Fall / Thanksgiving "Autumn Turkey "Glass Hanging Ornament NWT

Vintage Japan Papier Mâché Turkey Pair Candy Container Thanksgiving Figurines

New ListingAnnalee Turkey Pilgrim Thanksgiving Doll Holiday Decoration With Tag 2008

Thanksgiving Decor - Ceramic Bag with Turkey

Vintage Thanksgiving Turkey Figurine Autumn Fall Harvest Table Top Home Decor

Vintage Melted Plastic Popcorn Thanksgiving Indian Man & Woman

Turkey Plush Thanksgiving Stuffed Toy Vintage Animal Decor Hallmark Centerpiece

Suzi Skoglund Pilgrim Girl Thanksgiving Figurine w/Pie

Old West German Composition Tom Turkey Thanksgiving Decoration #2

Thanksgiving Ceramic Pottery Cornucopia Horn of Plenty Centerpiece E

New ListingVintage Silvestri Pilgrim Thanksgiving Holiday Boy Figure Holding Corn 10”

NEW Blue Sky Clayworks Halloween cat in Pumpkin with Pumpkin tail Tea Light

Antique Vntg German Bisque Thanksgiving Turkey Bird Dollhouse Miniature Animal

Vintage Post Cards (8) Thanksgiving 1906 Post Cards Holiday Some Embossed

(3) Thanksgiving Vintage Style Postcards & (6) Flash Cards E

THANKSGIVING PILGRIMS COUPLE 10” BOY & GIRL CERAMIC FIGURINES HOLDING BASKETS.

Vintage 1960’s Gurley Native American Indian Man Thanksgiving Candle Buffalo, NY

New ListingTHE PILGRIM PAIR 2015 Salt Pepper Shakers NIB 5" tall Publix collectibles

VINTAGE LOT OF 18 GURLEY THANKSGIVING CANDLES PILGRIMS TURKEY INDIANS

Lot of Seasonal Fall & Thanksgiving Decor

4 Piece Vintage Gurley Thanksgiving Candle Lot Turkey Pilgrim

New ListingVintage double sided fall autumn Thanksgiving double sided wall quilt pilgrims

Vintage 1978 Pom Pom Thanksgiving Ornaments

Vtg Danish Made Pilgrim Honeycomb Thanksgiving Decoration Handmade in Denmark

Thanksgiving Pilgrim Bear Figurine Planter-Fall Harvest Barrel-CuteCeramic Decor

2 New Tahua Pottery Christmas Reindeer Figurines. Home Decor Xmas Holiday

Best selling

Lenox Mini Pumpkin 10 Miniature Tree Ornaments Thanksgiving Halloween

Lenox Autumn Favorites Miniature Tree Ornaments Set of 10 Fall Pumpkin

LED Icicle Lights Outdoor Christmas Decorations 400led 8 Multicolor

Old World Christmas 24156 Glass Blown Pilgrim Thanksgiving Ornament

2013 Hallmark Giving Thanks 4th Snoopy Peanuts Gang Monthly Ornament Series

2021 Hallmark Ornament Friends "The One With All The Thanksgivings" Magic

Publix The Pilgrim Pair Thanksgiving Napkin Rings Holders Pilgrims Box 102476